#9
The Devil in Me is a Saw-style slasher set in a replica of H.H. Holmes' murder hotel, which is a better horror premise than most games manage. The trap mechanics and more active survival sequences give it a slightly different feel to House of Ashes, though I think it is the weaker game overall because the pacing is less consistent and some of the cast choices land badly. It still earns its spot here for groups who have already played House of Ashes and want another shared-story horror night on PS5 without repeating the same anthology entry. Go in with the right expectations: this is a horror film you play together, not a survival test.