#15
Labyrinthine supports up to eight players, which is actually rare in co-op horror and worth noting if your LAN has more bodies than the standard four-player limit allows for. Navigating procedural mazes in the dark while calling out positions to your group generates real shared tension, especially when the group is large enough that not everyone has the same information. The reason it sits here rather than in the top ten is that the gameplay loop goes narrower faster than the better picks. For one or two sessions with a bigger group it is solid. As a repeat rotation pick across a long night, it starts to feel limited.