#14
BOKURA is one of the strangest entries I looked at for this list, two players seeing entirely different versions of the same world, which means describing your screen to your partner is not a hint system, it is the entire mechanic. I found myself genuinely surprised by how well the concept held up across a full campaign. Two players only. It is also fairly short, so it will not anchor a LAN night on its own. If your group already burned through We Were Here Forever and wants one more communication puzzle before moving on, this is the one to grab next.